| Platinum | Papa Baird's |
| Gold | Second Street Grill |
| Silver | Bob's Burgers & Brew |
| Bronze | Powerhouse Grill |
| Top Pick | Crafted |
| Top Pick | Jean's Cottage Inn |
| Top Pick | Main Stop on the Ave |
| Top Pick | Major's Burgers on 3rd |
| Top Pick | Mama Corie's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Shari's |