| Platinum | Hoptown Wood Fired Pizza |
| Gold | Zac Zza's Pizza |
| Silver | Zac's Zzas |
| Bronze | Abby's Legendary Pizza |
| Top Pick | Flame and Brew Wood Fired Pizza |
| Top Pick | Magic's Pizza Shack |
| Top Pick | Mr Pizza |
| Top Pick | Valley Italian Pizza And Pasta |
| Top Pick | Westside Pizza |
| Top Pick | Wild Fired Pizza |