| Platinum | Nay's Heavenly Treats |
| Gold | Viera's Bakery |
| Silver | Pepe's Bakery |
| Bronze | Heaven's Cake |
| Top Pick | Nicoles Little Bit of Everything |
| Top Pick | Provisions Restaurant and Market |
| Top Pick | The Blooming Whisk LLC |
| Top Pick | Treats by Aly |
| Top Pick | White House Cafe |