| Platinum | Pizzaias Pizza |
| Gold | Zac Zza's Pizza |
| Silver | The Kiln |
| Bronze | Tonys Big Cheese Pizza |
| Top Pick | Abby's Legendary Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bron Yr Aur Brewing Co |
| Top Pick | Moxee Pizza |
| Top Pick | Round Table Pizza |
| Top Pick | Westside Pizza |
| Top Pick | Wild Fired Pizza |